Like Herding Cats: A Draft Manifesto for Panoptic Protest, particularly towards the Israel-Palestine Conflict.
by Madison Fischer
– An Introduction to this Blog, this Cause, and on accomplishing Strategic Conflict Resolution –
Hello, Bittersweet World-
My name is Madison. Like many bloggers, I am a twentysomething towards the end of my college career and seeking my true path in life…..not that I can ever know completely what that is, but the passion I have towards finding it has been pushing me through. When I’m not obsessing about the global implications of capitalism, consciousness, the world’s current economic order, and issues of global and social inequality, I spend my time as an active painter, singer, traveler, reader, student, hot-sauce connoisseur, INFP, and modern day radical.
Wait a minute…….
STOP.
I know what you’re thinking- seriously, I do. Everything else sounds fine, but really? A self-proclaimed radical? That word is -quite literally- thrown in everyone’s face by modern media as a negative buzz word to either scare or to show someone’s unwavering fanatical allegiance to a one-sided cause. “So…what’s different?” You ask. “Why should I even bother reading this at all?”
Ugh……I know, I know, everyone seems to be a ‘radical’ these days. Just hear me out completely, though- I am aware of the length of this ‘draft manifesto’, I was the one who wrote it. But every point made is significant to you and your personal future. You can trust me on that one enough to power through it…..I have faith in you. I know that no matter where you are or what you do, you will never be able to run from what the general population knows as radical conservatives, radical liberals, or radical religious zealots……the list goes on and it really does seem like the whole world has turned radical and has gone out of its f@&#ing mind.
But………the world isn’t, and they aren’t radicals. Although these groups of people are fundamentally extreme in their behavior, they are not introducing any new way of thinking and acting that is controversial, different, and effective. The world, and human beings as a species, have been this way since the dawning of Man and Woman. The atrocities that are happening in the world right now are products of our history and we seem to continue down the same path that we always have, usually with a large number of people running amok and spreading hatred, dissidence, greed, and the denial that we as human beings need to work together for survival; leaving a train-wreck of dysfunctional societies, mindsets, and behaviors behind on their feverish paths to finding not-so-actualized self-actualization.
But if you DO survive the whirlwind of zeal, lack of higher thought, and cynicism that overwhelms and blinds so many- you can take a look back down these paths in history, and see small groups of the world’s only sane people coming together slowly (but surely) to pick up the wreck and try to bring back order to our world…..piece by little piece.
In my individual story, I am trying to be one of those people cleaning up.
However, to understand this cause, my confidence, and the validity of thought and reasoning that has been put into this ‘manifesto’, a little bit of my history has to be shared. Spending the past five years focusing my higher education in subjects pertaining to Applied Psychology, Political Science, Comparative Religious Ethics, Multi-cultural Management, Marketing of Social Causes, and on the International Political Economy- I have also had the amazing opportunity of spending time working in Kabul, Afghanistan, accomplishing what I had once deemed an impossible feat; facilitating the successful integration of the first Afghan female staff members into an all male Afghan R&D firm, in the midst of war at the age of 21. In this unique situation, I learned the valuable technique of mediating on highly sensitive topics by means of empathetic reason to successfully accomplish my goals in a culture much different than my own.
So with that knowledge, and harnessing every ounce of drive, passion, and confidence in humanity I contain, I seek to once again attempt the seemingly impossible- promote unity and an alteration of modern protest techniques regarding topics that cause tremendous amounts of blind hatred, extreme polarization, and personal bias between people in a time and place in the world where we need to stick together the most. Taking a step back from my personal feelings about the Israel-Palestine Conflict, the goal I am trying to accomplish is this:
Sparking a publicly unbiased and unpolarized social movement that focuses on facilitating peace, mutual respect, humanity, and most importantly,
sharing the goal of achieving FAIR and JUST Conflict Resolution between Israel and Palestine
Why? Because it is our only choice. No matter how long we hold extreme anger and resentment from events that can’t be undone, all we can actually do now is to keep a cool head and look to the future to see how we can prevent history from rapidly repeating itself tomorrow. Innocent lives are on the line, and the only way to keep them alive is through reasonable steps to resolving the conflict. But by only thinking of the welfare of one side, decision-making becomes completely biased and ineffective. In this highly charged international and political atmosphere that we have in the world at this moment in time, there is no other option but to be reasonable and unpolarized.
And that idea, I have come to find, is true radicalism in this modern age.
So, in an effort to accelerate a just and realistic end to these bloody attacks, and to prevent a larger conflict from forming, my initial goal for encouraging modern protests to focus on Just and Fair Conflict Negotiation is to find ways of reasoning with local communities to unite on the basis of wanting the violence to end. For the benefit of not just Israelis and Palestinians, but of the citizens of the world also, we as supporters must let go of this predominant ‘black-and-white’ mentality and work together to form a cohesive social group- a unified effort to peer pressure both sides of the conflict to not try and ‘win’. There is no ‘winning’ in this situation. This is a modern conflict birthed by thousand-year-old feuds, and although we may never be able to stop it, we as protesters can facilitate an international pressure for a physical truce. For the preservation of all people involved, everyone must accept that in no actual reality will either population leave their homes, or have the land only for themselves, or have a world where there is religious and cultural hegemony, unless it ends with global mass murder or a complete genocide of an entire people. This doesn’t mean that both groups of people are equally at fault, nor are they even in control of what is going on politically. This current conflict is between the Israeli Government and an organization led by Hamas. We need to be realistic about our expectations regardless of our want for ethical idealism. Justice through the established guidelines of International Law takes time and serious work, but it is the only way of executing any liable form of reparation and formation of truly equal rights for the Palestinian people as well as securing the safety of Israeli citizens. Starting with baby-steps to learn how to run, we need to first put our efforts towards encouraging a mutual ‘cease fire’. It is going to be difficult, but if we truly care about the lives of innocent people, that is the first step to work towards if any at all.
In addition, we must also make an initiative to stabilize Palestine from the inside out, by encouraging international medical aid and to enforce efforts towards non-aggressive protection of the Palestinian people stuck in the cross-fire. Recognizing that Hamas is leading an individual militant organization that is not thinking of the welfare of his own people, the average Palestinian cannot be blamed for causing this conflict. In an attempt to break down this organization’s power to instill the safety of both Palestinians and Israelis, we need to provide reliable and secure support for Palestinians ‘on the ground’, discouraging any continued civilian support for Hamas. I wish to also harness alternative forms of protest (petitions, online media, letters to politicians, etc) used by an international force of protesters to put extreme international pressure on the U.S. to END the funding of this proxy, as well as put extreme pressure on the UN to not just hold Israel accountable for its war crimes, multiple breaches of International Law, and its legal and moral need to partake in reparation, but to also aid Palestine in adhering to global standards by making full efforts to actively stop any rogue attack from happening towards Israel.
However ‘unreasonable’ that may seem to some, it is technically, rationally, legally, and logically the only way to begin true efforts towards an end to this mass violence, and to try and prevent any future violence at hand. Israel has already agreed to a mutual cease fire: Many don’t trust their word due to the past, but now being internationally investigated by the UN and other groups on acts of ethnic cleansing, genocide, and brute colonialism- the whole world will be watching, and they will have everything to lose if they don’t (whether you agree with these charges or not). But if Hamas’ militant group cannot be subdued in their efforts to accomplish attacks, Israel will not stop their aggressive defensive/offensive strategies and the U.S. will continue to make excuses to be involved, while real reparation for the Palestinian citizens, the insured safety of the Israeli citizens, and the prosecution of the Israeli Government’s violations of International Law will never be actualized. This would mean a shit-storm of enough global-political outrage across the board to put humanity back into a situation that, frankly, no sane person wants to be in again.
Let’s think about this situation for a moment. With many people world-wide protesting their fury over the asymmetric playing field of this conflict, if peace efforts are not actualized or end up failing it will leave a vulnerability for any group or nation to be the ‘knight in shining armor’ to step in to potentially provide military support with the conviction of helping the Palestinians. But war strategy is war strategy- if full military support is provided, all that means is another player in a proxy. Add that to a cruel reality that if the U.S. still refuses to cut support to Israel (let’s be real for a second, if another nation’s military does actually step in on the other side, our support would turn from tax dollars into troops), and if Iran is still sending indirect support to Hamas, the situation would lead to multiple opposing world powers fueling these two fires- meaning that if this conflict were to internationally and politically escalate, it will open the door to a sanctioned start of a world war.
This is the very real possibility of extreme war developing if we continue to support either side of this conflict without any efforts towards peace and negotiation to leave room for reparation. To support any side of an international conflict, it is crucial to have full situational awareness of the scope of the current global-political atmosphere.
So in our efforts, we need to support reason, not blind emotion.
We need to support non-militant aid and peace efforts, not the perpetuation of hostilities.
For, to do the latter will only encourage death and destruction for many more people than just the Israelis and Palestinians, and will leave EVERYONE in the world with nothing but regret that we hadn’t dealt with it differently.
To be driven by the beliefs, motivations, and successes of every social leader to ever accomplish true change and progress in a world where almost everyone told them that they would fail, we must realize that to be truly progressive is to look forward and recognize that the future doesn’t always have to repeat itself, as long as we all make efforts to challenge our existing behaviors, mindsets, and attitudes.
This blog will document my struggle to accomplish an expression of true peace in a time where no one wants to let go of their fixed mindsets that a resolution to this conflict is not possible, thus unintentionally perpetuating the international support of the hostility and refusal to ‘cease fire’ between Hamas and the Israeli government. This failure can and will inevitably lead to a full blown proxy-to-war between multiple world powers if we don’t all sober up and think rationally about this conflict.
But I can’t do this alone. I am in desperate need of like-minded individuals who stand for these values and will form a team with me to help spread this mindset and support the end of mass bloodshed due to this conflict. If you believe in:
- being unbiased and unpolarized when publicly supporting innocent people stuck in a controversial conflict, regardless of your own personal views on which side you sympathize with
- being a revolutionary, a progressive, a creative and a lover of all human beings
- having allegiance to humanity, justice, and the sanctity of life in the face of war
- joining me to create a true humanitarian effort (no aid money, not even a cent, should go into our personal pockets)
If you are interested in joining this movement and would like to discuss ways of becoming involved, please reblog or share this draft manifesto to help spread the word and contribute to the growth of this movement, and feel free to message me here or email me at madisonfischer@hotmail.com. I will reply enthusiastically and without hesitation.
With Love,
M. Fischer
In a world where people pride in having radical views, this initiative for me is a call for the rational voices to rise up, stand together – even if we have differing view points. I will be keenly following your efforts and will try to pitch in as well. Wish you all the best!
Sam
LikeLike
Sam-
You are absolutely right, and I thank you so much for the support! Every individual can contribute to the spread of this rational peace movement, even if it is just a reblog or share.
Let’s hope for the best,
Madison
LikeLike
Good luck Madison (and thank you for the follow); you will find I’m not of a radical mind set – age perhaps – but I share your belief that we have to keep pressing and trying to correct the imbalances and injustices around us. I have learned a deal about the background to the seemingly intractable issues in the Middle East and especially the Palestine/Israeli conundrum from researching my father’s time their in the 1940s and it is clear there have been moment when chances opened that might have led to a better place than now. So keep working at your project and I will watch and cheer, if from a little way back. If you haven’t clicked through to the link in my blog to Sue King’s website, do. Having met her I would guess she is hewn from the same rock as you.
And on a slightly different note, reclaim ‘radical’ for people of passion not people of extreme. As a young man, being radical was a badge of inspiration, not as is portrayed today.
Geoff
LikeLike
Geoff,
Thank you for your comments and support. I will try my best, and also check out Sue King’s website- I appreciate the recommendation!
Cheers,
Madison
LikeLike
hm I like your proposal and point of view. You have certainly redefined radicalism. I am a Muslim, so I can translate the feelings of Muslims on the issue of Israel,call this a starting point towards the de-escalation of this conflict, if u may.
Yes it is true that most Muslims consider the state of Israel as illegitimate,there are historical facts, but we have been arguing over this for well over half a century now and it hasn`t taken us anywhere. Looking at the present scenario, Israel is a reality, no matter how brutal it maybe, it is a reality which cannot be ignored, and so is Palestine.
The real conflict here is about the rights, Palestinians were driven out of their land and their rights were usurped. If the world can somehow intervene in this situation to firstly ensure that conflict stops from both sides, and then arrange a process of negotiations where grievances from both sides are heard and sorted out.
A political/religious leader from Pakistan , Dr Tahir ul Qadri actually proposed that UN should immediately send a peace keeping force on Israel Gaza border and implement a strict ceasefire from both sides. This is a practical solution which can be implemented, but for some reason even UN seems reluctant to do absolutely anything to prevent more bloodshed.
Your ideas are truly revolutionary, we need to strive towards a society where everyone has freedom to practice their beliefs,no matter what they are.
I can be contacted at danialahmed.92@gmail.com
Regards
Danial Ahmed
Team Operation Pakistan
LikeLiked by 3 people
Danial,
Thank you for your support on this issue. It is sincerely appreciated, and I agree that an attention to the rights of Palestinians should be considered in a fair negotiation. I will be sure to emphasize that point in the future.
Kindest Regards,
Madison Fischer
LikeLike
Reblogged this on Operation Pakistan and commented:
Reblogging this post because it speaks of rising up from our prejudices and being a humanitarian,I strongly believe that deep down every religion preaches humanitarianism.
LikeLike
Reblogged this on Lex Solo's Political Rantings and commented:
Even though there are a couple of points this draft manifesto needs to address, it is probably the best route to take.
I like this kind of radicalism.
LikeLike
Not in an aggressive way, but in an effort to be as well-rounded as possible, what points did I miss? I would love any type of feedback to consider.
Kindest Regards,
Madison
LikeLike
I feel you are missing four key points:
1) The “creation” of the state of Palestine and as such ending the occupation, since it’s not even a country under international standards. And possibly with the support of the UN’s Peacekeeping troops as means of protection, during its first couple of years as a country so it can start building itself up.
2) A redistribution of land for Palestine, as the days go by Israel takes away more and more from them. There should be a discussion and an agreement reached regarding this matter.
3) The rights of Palestinians
4) A thorough investigation for both war crimes and human rights abuses from both sides since the beginning of the conflict (aka since the creation of the state of Israel after WWII).
Otherwise, I really like and agree with the route you’re proposing.
LikeLike
Today I broke down in tears and am in a numb state from this ongoing massacre in Gaza. I am following you and you have accomplished a feat in Afghanistan. I do believe that it is possible for like minded people to exert a positive energy for change so I support your intentions. However, if you have not read this article http://nadiaharhash.wordpress.com/2014/07/24/hamas-offers-reasonable-truce-greeted-by-deafening-silence/ you should, for balance. Israel is not the only one offering a truce or peace. Sadly, as you know from being in Afghanistan, we cannot depend on mainstream media to get the truth. Nadia has posted a wide array of different articles that provide history and context for the responses of Hamas and Palestine. And in no way can anyone justify this continued massacre, equal to genocide that Israel is inflicting on Gaza. Plus, people seem to forget the onslaught Israel inflicted for over two weeks on Palestinians about three Israelis they said were kidnapped when they knew they were dead. This is where I stand http://rigzenchomo.com/2014/07/12/buddha-cries-for-gaza/ Let’s see what we can do to create peace in this shattered world.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thank you for your article reference and support, it is much appreciated! I had not seen that blog, but am very happy to read that there is talk of a mutual truce, although it will take a lot of negotiation for the physical attacks to cease. You are very right on the fact that you really can’t trust ANY media source on a situation like this, where propaganda comes from both sides from inside of the conflict, sometimes without even meaning to, it is just biased because it is only viewing the conflict from one perspective.
Madison
LikeLike
I am sharing this, Ms. Fischer, in the hopes that cool reason will prevail. I have also been sharing this poem twice a day, in the hopes that people will read and eventually understand its meaning.
“Out beyond ideas of wrongdoing and rightdoing there is a field.
I’ll meet you there.
When the soul lies down in that grass, the world is too full to talk about.
Ideas, language, even the phrase ‘each other’ doesn’t make any sense.”
Rumi
Thank you.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I adore Rumi, and am also honored that you shared this blog. Thank you for your support, sincerely.
Madison
LikeLiked by 1 person
Some good thinking here and I support your exploration into true radicalism.
On the point of being unpolarised I would challenge the use of the label ‘terrorist’. It is a polarising word. You refer to some actions of the Israeli Government as crimes but you refer to Hamas’s identity as terrorist. I appreciate the need to be reasonable and recognise the violence of both sides but such language suggests that one side is redeemable and the other not.
Language is hard.
Shalom.
LikeLike
Thank you for your recommendation! I truly appreciate the feedback, and feel that you are correct on that point.
Madison
LikeLiked by 1 person